Diplomdarbs
Uzņēmējdarbība un tiesības
Tiesības
The Analysis of the 2015 Amendments to the Latvian Law, I...-
The Analysis of the 2015 Amendments to the Latvian Law, Increasing the Liability of LLC Members of the Board of Directors
Nr. | Sadaļas nosaukums | Lpp. |
Summary | 1 | |
Table of abbreviations | 5 | |
Introduction | 6 | |
1. | The institute of limited liability | 7 |
1.1. | Historical overview | 7 |
1.1.1. | The Roman law | 7 |
1.1.2. | Byzantine Chreokoinonia | 8 |
1.1.3. | Medieval law | 8 |
1.1.4. | Early Modern Denmark and England | 8 |
1.1.5. | Modern period in the United States | 9 |
1.1.6. | Summary of the chapter | 10 |
1.2. | The purpose of limited liability | 10 |
1.2.1. | Stimulus and diversification of investment | 10 |
1.2.2. | Cost saving | 11 |
1.2.3. | Transferable shares as an equivalent | 11 |
1.2.4. | Creditor scrutiny and optimal risk-taking | 12 |
1.2.5. | Summary of the chapter | 12 |
1.3. | The main exceptions from the liability protection – a comparative research | 12 |
1.3.1. | Germany | 13 |
1.3.2. | The United Kingdom | 15 |
1.3.3. | Netherlands | 17 |
1.3.4. | Latvia | 19 |
1.3.5. | Summary of the chapter | 21 |
2. | The business judgment rule | 23 |
2.2. | Analysis of the case law on handing over insolvent companies’ documents | 25 |
2.3. | Analysis of the case law on the recovery of tax debts form MBDs | 26 |
2.4. | Summary of the chapter | 26 |
3. | Analysis of the Amendments | 27 |
3.1. | The Article 72.1 of the Latvian Insolvency Law | 27 |
3.1.1. | The aim of the Article 72.1 of the Latvian Insolvency Law | 28 |
3.1.2. | The analysis of the Article 72.1 of the Latvian Insolvency Law | 28 |
3.1.3. | Summary of the chapter | 30 |
3.2. | The chapter XI of the Latvian Law on Taxes and Fees | 30 |
3.2.1. | The aim of the chapter XI to the Latvian Law on Taxes and Fees | 32 |
3.2.2. | The analysis of the chapter XI to the Latvian Law on Taxes and Fees | 32 |
3.2.3. | Summary of the Chapter | 36 |
Conclusion | 37 | |
Bibliography | 39 | |
Annex 1 | 44 | |
Annex 2 | 45 | |
Annex 3 | 46 | |
Annex 4 | 47 | |
Figure 1 | 48 |
Conclusion
The purpose of this bachelor theses was to determine whether the Amendments are appropriate instruments to achieving their intended goals that are set in the reports on the initial assessment of proposed Amendments (annotations). In other words, the author intended to find out, will the Amendments prevent MBDs from abusing their limited liability or rather trigger further circumvention and ignorance of the law, hence deteriorating the overall economic development of the country.
The author’s hypothesis was that the Amendments are inappropriate instruments and will cause further circumvention and ignorance of the law, and will be detrimental to the Latvian economy.
The first part of this thesis was devoted to the establishment of the criteria for the analysis of the Amendments. It was found that the main principle of the liability protection is the stimulus of investment though a decrease in costs of doing business, an opportunity to diversify investment and a guarantee of optimal risk-taking.
The analysis of the conditions under which MBDs can be exempt from the liability protection in other jurisdictions was performed, and it showed that these condition should be consistent with the main principle of limited liability. The Amendments are also such conditions and therefore too have to be in line with the principle. However, it is expected that the Amendments will discourage people from becoming MBDs and trigger emigration of Latvian companies, therefore decreasing investment in Latvia. Moreover, these norms will again put MBDs in a position where they have to control every step of their managing agents. Hence, the Amendments are against the stimulus of investment, diversification and cost saving principles of the liability protection. Consequently, the evolutionary development of the institute of limited liability is going in the backwards direction as even the Roman law, Byzantine Chreokoinonia etc. tried to make investment in business activity attractive and therefore provided for incentives to encourage people to perform such an activity. Latvian law, conversely, makes the post of a MBD highly unattractive.
…
The subject of the thesis is the new amendments to the law increasing personal liability of managing directors of limited liability companies. The new amendments gained a lot of public attention and criticism from industry professionals. The author took the opportunity to perform a detailed analysis on whether the public criticism is objectively grounded and whether the amendments can be considered as effective and necessary. The thesis covers a wide range of issues related to the board liability, starting from historical perspective, regulation in other countries, practical problems leading to the amendments and, finally, analysis of the wording and application of Constitutional court’s test for legitimacy. The thesis identifies shortcomings of the amendments, not only the expected ones, but also by looking from different perspective, when trying to place the amendments into the structure of the whole legal system of Latvia.
- Contract on Goods Sale
- Copyright Protection in Digital Environment - Peer to Peer Networks
- The Analysis of the 2015 Amendments to the Latvian Law, Increasing the Liability of LLC Members of the Board of Directors
-
Tu vari jebkuru darbu ātri pievienot savu vēlmju sarakstam. Forši!Contract on Goods Sale
Paraugs augstskolai2
-
Copyright Protection in Digital Environment - Peer to Peer Networks
Diplomdarbs augstskolai41
Novērtēts! -
Regulation of Patient Rights and Medical Privacy in Latvia: Current Situation and Proposed Amendments
Diplomdarbs augstskolai55
Novērtēts! -
Social Dialogue and Problems of Working Environment for the European Social Model
Eseja augstskolai4
-
Judical Trials do not Help Victims Heal
Eseja augstskolai7